| Jack Simpson Centre-Back | 20/21 | AFC Bournemouth Rangers FC | 9 | 23/24 | | 0 | 1.123 |
| Kristian Pedersen Left-Back | 22/23 | Birmingham City 1.FC Köln | 155 | 23/24 | | 2 | 580 |
| Ryan Manning Left-Back | 20/21 | Queens Park Rangers Swansea City | 87 | 23/24 | | 32 | 998 |
| Sondre Tronstad Central Midfield | 15/16 | Huddersfield Town FK Haugesund | 0 | 23/24 | | 28 | 2.725 |
| Britt Assombalonga Centre-Forward | 21/22 | Middlesbrough FC Adana Demirspor | 152 | 22/23 | | 11 | 546 |
| Ben Hamer Goalkeeper | 20/21 | Huddersfield Town Swansea City | 15 | 22/23 | | 20 | 550 |
| Ryan Hedges Right Winger | 19/20 | Barnsley FC Aberdeen FC | 31 | 21/22 | | 68 | 944 |
| Jake Bidwell Left-Back | 19/20 | Queens Park Rangers Swansea City | 122 | 21/22 | | 85 | 930 |
| Morgan Whittaker Right Winger | 20/21 | Derby County Swansea City | 25 | 21/22 | | 0 | 334 |
| Aden Flint Centre-Back | 19/20 | Middlesbrough FC Cardiff City | 39 | 20/21 | | 4 | 455 |
| Daryl Horgan Left Midfield | 18/19 | Preston North End Hibernian FC | 40 | 20/21 | | 40 | 753 |
| Declan John Left-Back | 17/18 | Cardiff City Rangers FC | 22 | 19/20 | | 0 | 760 |
| Lee Peltier Right-Back | 14/15 | Huddersfield Town Cardiff City | 11 | 19/20 | | 0 | 1.833 |
| Scott Sinclair Left Winger | 16/17 | Aston Villa Celtic FC | 0 | 19/20 | | 78 | 1.249 |
| Ali Al-Habsi Goalkeeper | 17/18 | Reading FC Al-Hilal SFC | 78 | 19/20 | | 0 | 775 |
| Bobby De Cordova-Reid Attacking Midfield | 18/19 | Bristol City Cardiff City | 109 | 19/20 | | 82 | 403 |
| Greg Cunningham Centre-Back | 18/19 | Preston North End Cardiff City | 103 | 19/20 | | 8 | 403 |
| Tomás Mejías Goalkeeper | 18/19 | Middlesbrough FC Omonia Nicosia | 8 | 19/20 | | 0 | 359 |
| Anthony Pilkington Left Winger | 14/15 | Norwich City Cardiff City | 0 | 18/19 | | 26 | 1.609 |
| Sam Clucas Central Midfield | 17/18 | Hull City Swansea City | 47 | 18/19 | | 131 | 351 |
| Craig Noone Right Winger | 12/13 | Brighton & Hove Albion Cardiff City | 36 | 17/18 | | 60 | 1.827 |
| Joe Garner Centre-Forward | 16/17 | Preston North End Rangers FC | 43 | 17/18 | | 32 | 315 |
| Emyr Huws Defensive Midfield | 16/17 | Wigan Athletic Cardiff City | 16 | 16/17 | | 18 | 172 |
| Charlie Mulgrew Centre-Back | 08/09 | Wolverhampton Wanderers Aberdeen FC | 6 | 16/17 | | 59 | 2.983 |
| Scott Malone Left-Back | 14/15 | Millwall FC Cardiff City | 68 | 16/17 | | 36 | 559 |