| Ben Turner Centre-Back | 11/12 | Coventry City Cardiff City | 72 | 15/16 | | 0 | 1.540 |
| Alex Revell Centre-Forward | 14/15 | Rotherham United Cardiff City | 24 | 15/16 | | 0 | 306 |
| Shaun Maloney Attacking Midfield | 14/15 | Wigan Athletic Chicago Fire FC | 30 | 15/16 | | 20 | 214 |
| Tom Adeyemi Central Midfield | 14/15 | Birmingham City Cardiff City | 35 | 15/16 | | 23 | 341 |
| Adam Le Fondre Centre-Forward | 14/15 | Reading FC Cardiff City | 70 | 14/15 | | 53 | 209 |
| Sol Bamba Centre-Back | 12/13 | Leicester City Trabzonspor | 52 | 14/15 | | 51 | 936 |
| Jure Travner Centre-Back | 10/11 | Watford FC St. Mirren FC | 0 | 14/15 | | 1 | 1.482 |
| Anton Ferdinand Centre-Back | 13/14 | Queens Park Rangers Antalyaspor | 0 | 14/15 | | 21 | 362 |
| Tal Ben Haim Centre-Back | 13/14 | Queens Park Rangers Standard Liège | 0 | 14/15 | | 37 | 352 |
| Don Cowie Right Midfield | 11/12 | Watford FC Cardiff City | 88 | 14/15 | | 32 | 1.105 |
| Kyle Lafferty Centre-Forward | 08/09 | Burnley FC Rangers FC | 82 | 14/15 | | 30 | 2.191 |
| Andrew Taylor Left-Back | 11/12 | Middlesbrough FC Cardiff City | 33 | 14/15 | | 26 | 1.093 |
| Robert Earnshaw Centre-Forward | 11/12 | Nottingham Forest Cardiff City | 97 | 13/14 | | 1 | 994 |
| Robert Earnshaw Centre-Forward | 12/13 | Cardiff City Toronto FC | 23 | 13/14 | | 1 | 386 |
| Lee Naylor Left-Back | 06/07 | Wolverhampton Wanderers Celtic FC | 81 | 13/14 | | 0 | 2.583 |
| Dimitrios Konstantopoulos Goalkeeper | 10/11 | Coventry City AOK Kerkyra | 24 | 13/14 | | 98 | 1.143 |
| Kelvin Wilson Centre-Back | 11/12 | Nottingham Forest Celtic FC | 81 | 13/14 | | 46 | 770 |
| Kamil Zayatte Centre-Back | 10/11 | Hull City Konyaspor | 16 | 13/14 | | 22 | 921 |
| Sone Aluko Right Winger | 08/09 | Birmingham City Aberdeen FC | 0 | 12/13 | | 48 | 1.423 |
| Ryan Allsop Goalkeeper | 11/12 | Millwall FC IF Höttur | 0 | 12/13 | | 0 | 65 |
| Mido Centre-Forward | 10/11 | Middlesbrough FC Ajax Amsterdam | 0 | 12/13 | | 1 | 700 |
| Caleb Folan Centre-Forward | 10/11 | Hull City Colorado Rapids | 31 | 11/12 | | 0 | 337 |
| Mark Howard Goalkeeper | 07/08 | Cardiff City St. Mirren FC | 0 | 11/12 | | 4 | 1.523 |
| Cédric Baseya Centre-Forward | 08/09 | Southampton FC LOSC Lille | 1 | 11/12 | | 0 | 1.157 |
| Papa Bouba Diop Central Midfield | 10/11 | Portsmouth FC AEK Athens | 0 | 11/12 | | 16 | 413 |